Writing Dialogue

Discussion through works of art encourage how to approach ambiguous and complex ideas, thoughts, and feelings. The MFAH offers a democratic space where students and teachers can develop, practice and articulate these habits of mind. Remember that the quality of the conversation is what is important, not finding the artist’s “answer.” Slow down and take the time to make careful observations. Talk about what you notice, and try to avoid jumping to conclusions and interpretations. Be sure to give enough time for silent looking and thinking.

Work of Art

During his forty-five years at Tuskegee Institute, P.H. Polk photographed dozens of notable figures.  George Washington Carver was a subject of inexhaustible interest to Polk.  As director of Tuskegee’s Agricultural Institute, Carver devoted his life to improving agriculture in the South.  Products he derived from crops such as peanuts and soybeans helped free the South’s economy from its dependence on cotton.  Polk deeply admired Carver as a scientist, teacher, and artist, and he captured the many aspects of Carver’s personality by photographing him in different settings and poses.

Polk’s portraits of Carver, such as this one taken in his laboratory in 1930, are informal, improvised, and personal.  Here, the viewer looks through the scientific apparatus that clutters Carver’s laboratory table to catch him, flask in hand, conducting an experiment.  The light focuses attention on the figure and on objects in the foreground, and illuminates Carver’s hands and forehead.  Although it seems to be a casual shot, the photograph is actually carefully composed to show Carver as a hard worker and as a wise man.

Prentice Hall Polk, an African-American photographer, created a record of the daily life around him.  Polk was born in Bessemer, Alabama, in 1898, and studied at the Tuskegee Institute, founded in 1881 by Booker T. Washington as a training ground in the basic trades such as carpentry, plumbing, and agriculture.  Although Polk had wanted to become a painter, the school did not offer such training, so instead he became one of the first students in the institute’s new photography department, where he studied the basic theory and techniques of the medium.  After marrying and moving to Chicago in the early 1920s, Polk apprenticed with a commercial photographer and acquired a deepened commitment to his trade.  In 1927, he returned to the Tuskegee Institute to teach photography.  Except for a brief period when he ran his own portrait studio, Polk spent the remainder of his career at the institute and was named its official photographer in 1939.

P.H. Polk was not recognized as an important American artist until the early 1970s when the body of work he had produced between 1920 and 1950 became widely known.  In addition to his documentation of George Washington Carver inside and outside of the laboratory, Polk skillfully created studio portraits of family members, the social, political, and intellectual elite around the Institute, and candid portrayals of people from nearby rural communities.

Conversation

• Describe the different elements of the photograph

• Look at the fall of light in this work. Where does the light come from? Is it natural or artificial?

• How does light affect the figure? And the objects?

• How does the character mimic the objects in the composition of this photograph?

• Describe the artist’s use of black and white within the work. How would this image be different in color?

• What visual cues are juxtaposed in the artwork? For example, look at light and dark in the foreground and background, the elongated and round bottle shapes, and the contrast between the human figure and the immaterial objects.

• What does the artist tell us about the subject in this photograph, George Washington Carver?

• As director of Tuskegee’s Agricultural Institute, George Washington Carver devoted his life to improving agriculture in the South.  What aspects of Carver’s personality does the artist capture in this photograph? What does Carver’s gaze tell us?

• What is the effect of the light captured in this photograph? Discuss how the artist uses light to create a sense of intimacy.

• Consider the relationship between the human figure and the immaterial objects he is working with. Why do you think the artist would chose to place equal emphasis on human and object?

• During his forty-five years at Tuskegee Institute, P.H. Polk photographed dozens of notable figures. Do the framing and composition hint at a monumental photograph or is this more of a snapshot? Why? Is there a tension between the seriousness of the character and way in which the artist has photographed him? Why do you think the artist created this duality?

• Tuskegee Institute was a training institute for manual trades such as carpentry, plumbing, architecture and even photography, of which the artist became one of the first students and later a teacher. How does this photograph emphasize the importance of manual labor?

Subject Matter

Assessment

Writing Dialogue

•  Divide the class into groups. Discuss the portrait and have students determine as much information as they can about the individual characters.

• Using these visual clues, complete a character analysis.

•  Have each group develop dialogues and dramatic presentations to share with the class.

Resources

Resources Available to Order

Check our online collection module for further information.